
'Danish photographer Asger Carlsen began his career at 16 when he sold a photo he took of the police yelling at him and his friends for burning a picket fence to the local paper. For the next ten years Asger worked as a crime photographer before moving on to shooting ads for magazines. Then one day while messing around on his computer he created an image of a face with a bunch of eyes that led him to the distorted photographs he has become known for. His eerie and often humorous work makes you question what is human, and has been exhibited and published internationally.
'The images of Carlsen occupy the hazy cloud-cuckoo land between analog and digital photography. His pictures maintain an interesting haphazardness, a truth-before-the lens aesthetic, which is combined with eerie digital manipulations. The apparent on-camera flash and black and white tones further heighten the disconnect between the “real” and the fabricated. Carlsen often employs the visual cues of snapshot photography to suggest a physical, temporal connection between the photographer and the subject. His images depict a version of reality that is both firsthand and dissembling.
'Persons with prosthetic legs fresh from the wood-shop, or those who may be blessed with backward-bending knees are shown as ordinary as anyone else. One image, similar to William Eggleston’s photograph of a man touching delicately an orange United States Air Force craft, depicts a man kissing, groping a towering mound of otherworldly ectoplasm. Carlsen’s microcosm equalizes all disparate activity; lycanthropes and Janus-faced characters coolly inhabit scenes lit by the glare of the camera’s clinical flash. All of which suggests both the degree to which the camera normalizes and objectifies experience, as well as the reticence of viewers to accept as factual all forms of photographic vision. Carlsen grafts a truthful and authoritative aesthetic upon deliberately fanciful constructions.' -- collaged
____
Extras
Interview with Asger Carlsen
Asger Carlsen exhibition
_____
Further
Asger Carlson Website
AC portfolio & interview @ Whiteloup
AC interviewed @ Vice
AC portfolio & interview @ Empty Kingdom
AC @ we are CASEY Agency
AC's book 'Hester'
AC's book 'Wrong' @ Carlson Projects
AC @ Twitter
AC portfolio @ tinyvices
AC portfolio & interview @ Dazed Digital
'WE BET YOU’VE NEVER SEEN NUDES LIKE THIS!'
'Artists Asger Carlsen and Alex Prager Kibitz About their Corporeal Selves'
'Asger Carlsen: Skræmmende og manipulerende'
Downloadable mixtape by Asger Carlsen @ Sound Advice
______
Interview
from APhotoEditor

I read in an interview that you were a crime scene photographer?
AC: People sometimes get that confused. I was a crime scene photographer, but that was when I was out of high school. So I was 17, and then did that for ten years.
Who did you work for? A police department?
AC: Newspapers. I was a full-on newspaper photographer. I started out as an intern, and saw how it was done. Then I bought a police scanner, and would respond to the calls. Car accidents and stuff. Eventually, I did photograph a bit for the police.
You’ll have to forgive me a bit here. My wife is a therapist, and my mother-in-law is a therapist, and now, being an interviewer, I’ve kind of morphed into this guy who tries to read the tea leaves. It sounds to me like there was a lot of darkness going on in your job, and in your head, and all of a sudden, it popped up out of the shadows, into this style that became yours.
AC: Certainly, there is an understanding of how those crime scene scenarios could look like. The work certainly represents my time as a newspaper photographer.
You can dig into that. You can see how I was standing in front of a car accident, photographing it. It’s just different objects.
I have some students, and we were looking at some work last week that was really super-digi. Over-saturated, hyper-real, hopped up, textured and degraded. I talked about that, and these are younger students, and they couldn’t see it. That archive that we have in our head, of the cinematic and celluloid look, they don’t have that baseline. Their baseline is digital reality.
They can’t tell the difference between the super-saturated color look on the screen, and what you see when you walk out your door. Their brains are just different now.
AC: They are different. Do you think they understand my work differently than you understand it?
Sure. I would think they have to. I showed “Wrong” to students last year, and they ate it up. Ate it up. I’m curious to see what happens when this generation of students, who has only grown up in the digi-verse, when they’re mature enough as artists to make shit that we can’t even imagine.
AC: I’m sure in ten or twenty years, the files being produced by these random Canon cameras, that’s going to be a style that people will try to copy again.
The sci-fi reference in your work are so strong, and I don’t even consider myself a sci-fi geek. What did you read or see that ended up percolating into your work.
AC: I was inspired by painters, different art movements and all these obvious classical references. There’s a certain awkwardness in the work, and maybe that’s my attempt to try to fit into a photography style. Part of the reason why I became a photographer is that there was a certain loneliness in it, a searching for something. I think the work is a bit about that as well.
Trying to find my spot. Maybe I am a dark person? (Thinks about it.) I am a dark person.
You certainly have it in there.
AC: I felt like an outsider when I grew up, for sure. There are certain things I’m good at, and photography is one of them. But I was not a success in school, not a success in many things, but there was this one thing I could do.
___
Show





























*
p.s. Hey. Today a silent, dedicated reader of this blog named Carolyn Fliest takes over and goes guest-curator in my galerie, and you get this very cool show by Danish photographer Asger Carlsen as a result, so enjoy, and thank you so very much for the intervention, Carolyn! Otherwise, Happy New Year! You guys awake and okay today? I think I'm feeling very slightly better this morning maybe. Let's see ... oh, the knockdown awesome writer, dancer, and much more Jack Dickson aka d.l. Jax wrote a radio play titled 'Rio', which he describes as 'a torrid tale of football and infidelity', and it's being broadcast on Radio Scotland on this very day at 11:30 am GMT. If you're awake at that time, you can listen to it live by clicking this. If you weren't awake at that time, you can listen to it anyway, so, if that's the case, click this. Anyway, I'm going to listen, and you should listen too 'cos it's sure to be pretty great. Oh, and this is nice for me: Last night there was a big on- and offline ceremony/ reading where the two big annual Alt Lit prizes, the Alt Lit Gossip Awards and the Beachies, were handed out, and I won a Beachy for 'Best Nice Guy', and since the Beachies are awarded by Beach Sloth, who seems like the nicest guy ever, that's pretty cool. So, thank you kindly, Beach Sloth, wherever you are. ** Misanthrope, Okay, bed, sensible. I had a quiet as usual night. Uh, watched TV, some old Hollywood movie about Toulouse Lautrec with Zsa Zsa Gabor in it that was dubbed into French and was obviously filmed on a set in Hollywood and didn't even have a single authentic Paris establishing shot in it even, and there was something enjoyably wrong and pomo about watching that, and that was pretty much my NYE. Hooray for your nephew! Yeah, this sickness is leaving so slowly and sluggishly, its weird, but I guess my health has its reasons. ** Jax, Hey! HNY! I'll be listening, probably live, assuming I finish this in time, and, otherwise, momentarily afterwards. Awesome, congrats! Banana bread, oh, I need. I haven't seen 'Moon', but I've also read good things. And it was ... ? ** David Ehrenstein, Thank you, sir. Well, please do tell Wilson that, thank you. Great that you're working on a new chapter of 'RBHP', and that it circles around O'Hara's typewriter is a most exciting development. ** Postitbreakup, HNY, Josh! Oh, no, my embargo is tolerable, no worries. I think NY in France is pretty much the same level of big deal that it is in the States. All the stores and everything are closed today, so that's how you judge bigness, I guess. ** Flit, Flit! You made a deliciously earlier than expected return! There is or at least may be a God perhaps. Thanks for talking back to the folks that were informed and excited because of you. You still there? How's today? ** 5STRINGS, There are definitely those who agree with you about English boys, so there must be a truth therein. I still think the French would probably win that prize for me if I were more okay with nationalist categories and less queazy about objectification and all that weird 'me' stuff. Okay, your NYE had a great sound and tasty PR and all that, so, whatever you did, it beat mine for sure. Nice! ** Creative Massacre, Hey, big M! Thanks a lot! The very same to you, pal! Bookstores in NYC: Okay, here are my recommendations, and locals will probably have more: St. Marks Bookshop. Housing Works. Mast Books. McNally Jackson. The Strand. Everyone, Creative Massacre is heading to NYC and is looking for good bookstores to visit while there. I just listed a few I know/like. Any other suggestions for her? Thanks! ** Unknown/Pascal, Hi! HNY! I'm better-ish, I would say. Dude, I was very prideful to have the Poetry Library here, natch. Brighton, nice, seemingly. Very awesome if the FW Day can happen, thank you kindly. HNY again! ** MANCY, Hi, M. Oh, I'll check them out today then if they're only there temporarily, cool. Gotcha on 'Blue Pill'. Did you go the party? I would've bailed and done the stay at home/fireworks thing, but that's me, and I'm sickish, so probably the party was the way to go, right? Did you go? Aw, thanks about my Metazen thing, man. ** Toniok, Hey and Happy New Year to you, Mr. K! Yeah, I think the slaves do get better, or maybe I get more discerning about the quality of the texts or something, or maybe word has gotten around in the slave world about my monthly selection thing, and they're starting to understand that their profile texts are an art form, and they're literally getting better at it, it's weird. 2013, yes! ** _Black_Acrylic, Greatest 2013 to you, Ben! What's Hogmanay? Hope you had the majorest blast last night, pal. ** Thomas Moronic, Hey, T! Obviously very, very good to see you! I know, the Chooseme text was a heartbreaker, no? I read your Fanzine list yesterday when I got lucky vis-a-vis my Facebook time and my news feed. Very cool and informative, man. Everyone, honorable and brilliant and longterm d.l. and writer Thomas Moronic did a Best of 2012 list for the great Fanzine site, and it's even more fun, well-written, and thought-provoking than the usual 2012 Top Ten list, and it has even got a cool name: 'Past Tense'. Read it, yeah. It's here. Hope you had a great night. Hope to get to see more often both here and in the real version. ** Cobaltfram, HYN! Okay, cool, I promise to accept your future avalanche of saintliness-derived gifts with grace. I like some of Anne Carson, yeah. Sometimes it's too clinical or something for me. I'm really looking forward to her sequel of 'Autobiography of Red' that's coming out this year. I hope your family shebang today passes with minimal prayer. ** Ken Baumann, Ken! I feel like I need to see the 48 frames thing. So far, every time I've read/heard something about it that's negative, I get 'stick in the mud' vibes from the opinion, so I want to know the personal truth about it, I guess. I might sit on the aisle though, just in case. Oh, no, my cinematic parade is so abstract at this point that any shit upon it just adds a kind of humanly, nice quality. Me too: I was in-house when the years changed. I was asleep actually. It was okay. No, I didn't catch your tap essay, awesome! I'll do that as soon as this is safely online. Everyone, the great Ken Baumann wrote a 'tap essay'. I just glanced at it, and it looks really exciting and mysterious. You should go read/look at it like I'm going to do, I think. You can, in Ken's words, 'click through it', here. And he says he 'was inspired to after reading/ tapping through/ digging FISH. You can download and read FISH here/on your iPhone. It's about a five minute read.' Follow Ken's leads. Always.. HNY, buddy! ** Sypha, I did see it, but I didn't actually click through and read it because I think I was just about to go make my dinner at the time. Iow, I'll go read that in just a few minutes. Yay! Everyone, here's Sypha with, in his words, 'a list of all the books I read during my five year reading experiment. It seems appropriate to mention it here, seeing this blog was one of the big inspirations for me branching out my reading tastes and becoming a better reader in general.' Thanks for the kind words, James. ** Will, Hi, Will, HNY! Maybe he did. That would explain why we both thought so. My faint memory is that I read that in The Wire? Whatever. Sir, I would love and be very honored if you want to do a post about Fernow, either re: Vatican Shadow or however you want to do that. That would be fantastic! Thank you for wanting to, no matter what. I hope your wife is feeling much better today. Major sympathy from a fellow if rising sufferer. ** Kiddiepunk, Mikey! You got 2013 way before we got it. I assume it's going okay there. It's going okay here. Quiet out, whoa. Light rain. No, wait, the rain stopped. Sort of sun. Nobody in the park. Decent temperature. Business class, sweet. Love of utter bigness back to you guys! ** Steevee, Thanks, Steevee, and a very happy new year to you too, my friend! ** Schlix, Hi, Uli! HNY! Me? Well, I watched that silly Toulouse Lautrec Hollywood movie I mentioned up above. Ate my usual veggie dog sandwiches and the second to last bite of Xmas buche. I worked on a blog post about Isabelle Huppert. Uh, I think that was it apart from some sickness-related coughing and stuff. Shiny day! ** A white fiction resumes its punctuality, Hi! Happy New Year! I vaguely remember that sentence of mine. Thank you. 2013 is going to be great for you, for me, maybe for everyone, I think. Love, me. ** Andrew, Hi. HYN again! And again! ** Slatted Light, Yes! The one and only you right here! So very sweet to see you, David! You good? Thank you, yeah, I thought those were some pretty good texts, but they only reached their full potential as your shards. Beautiful poem, sir. Very nice sniper-ish use of italics too. I hope your now fairly long past NY crossover moment was a lovely one, D., and take good care, and take a bunch of love. ** We are now safely inside 2013, and I hope you will spend some today wandering through the Asger Carlsen show, and, yeah, see you tomorrow.
35 comments:
congrats on your beachie!!! well-deserved. & we made it through nye. i'm already 5 hours 22 minutes into my birthday and I was unconscious for over half which feels like an excellent start
Thanks for the RIo shout-out: man, I hope you can understand the accents
VERY cool on your Beachy, Dennis: it couldn't go to a nicer guy! Saved you some banana bread but am afraid you'll have to ingest it virtually - thus conjuring up an Asger Carlsen esque photo: thanks So much for introducing me to this guy, Carolyn - some wonderfully squirmy images there and I enjoy a good squirm from time to time.
We recorded but didn't watch 'Moon', so I still don't know if it was as good as it should be. Curled up with Season 2 of 'Deadwood' instead...talking of wich, is Tarantino's 'Durango Unchained' out in France yet? I defo wanna see it and I think it's on here...somwhere. Will find out.
Happy birthday, Postitbreakup!
Wow, these are terrific. I can totally see the crime scene photography, and of course belmer.
Greetings from borneo. More when I can get to a real keyboard.
Bill
It was pretty staggering and really nice to find Asger Carlsen coming out of my computer at 7a on 1/1/13. He's amazing. The video and written interviews were interesting as well. My eyes are sort of crossed, so I'll have to come back to it later today. [That has nothing to do with a hangover. I slept through most of last night until some jackass set off a firework-y thing outside my window. It'll be interesting to see what the fire escape looks like when the sun comes up. At least he wasn't wasted enough to point it at my windows.]
JAX: Can't wait to tune into the rebroadcast of your play when I'm more awake!
postitbreakup: Happiest bday to you, man!
Flit: Really enjoyed the Sandwell DIstrict post.
Dennis: A happy one to you, D. Congrats on the Beachy.
hope your ailment vanishes. My total sympathies. I thought I'd given myself food poisoning for xmas, but it's lasted way too long. Sleep is finally starting to do the fixing thing, maybe. Wish that was an easier switch to flip.
I must say, I get a lot of good inspiration and vibes when you say you feel like shit, but you're doing the blog anyway. Not that I'm wishing that you stay ill.
Hey, y'all.
Njr
Carlsen is somehting of a "find."Very Hans Bellmer.
The film you saw a snatch of was Moulin Rouge (1952) , directed by John Huston (and not to be confused with that Baz Luhrman monstrosity with Nicole Kidman) It was Zsa Zsa's greatest role. The poor dear is legless, bed-ridden and barely hanging on as the century mark looms. She's being cared for (in a manner of speaking) by the husband rancesca calls "the phony Pricne." And indeed he is. He's a faded ggolo who bought the title for cash. Francesca squabbles with hm consgtantly for access to her mother. But there's sover little of Zsa Zsa left to squabble over.
Hey. Just a correction to say that I fucked up at the top of the p.s. Jack Dickson's radio play is being broadcast tomorrow, the 2nd, not today. So use those links tomorrow instead if you want to hear it. Sorry about that.
you really deserve the title "Best Nice Guy" I concur!
Happy New Year Dennis! Let's leave 2013 with our new novels wrapped in blankets and ready for the world!!
xoxox
On NY1 (a local all-news cable channel), Entertainment Weekly's Owen Gleiberman ran down his top 10 list last night. When he got to ZERO DARK THIRTY, he said "Finally, a film bold enough to suggest that 'enhanced interrogation' worked to find Osama bin Laden." I was disgusted. Finally, a film critic who may as well have set out to prove Glenn Greenwald's point.
Gleiberman is a stupid as greenwald. No mater how uch you show them that the film DOESN'T say torture provided crucial information to finding Osama they'll insist that it does.
By showing torture Kathy no more approves of it than Hitchcock approves of satbbing women to death in a show in Psycho
that carlsen is interesting, thanks, carolyn!
happy new year, dennis, and congrats on the nice guy award, which is more than deserved and will cut a nice figure next to the marquis de sade award on your shelf. nye was very quiet here. my mom got her 86-yo partner up at midnight to drink a glass of champagne and eat a berliner with us (not a berlin citizen but a kind of doughnut), and then he went back to bed and we followed him shortly after, and that was that. a friend postet a "here's to even lower expectations for 2013" cartoon on fb, and that does seem to make sense, but actually, the stakes for 2013 to be better than 2012 for me are not set very high. i'll start with eating the leftover berliner and then we'll see.
If I would move to Europe, I would move to France. That's the great thing about Europe, it's a wonderful melting pot. Objectification and all that weird "me" stuff? Can you judge people's character based on it's appearance? Haha, it was fun, I had a good time. I got fairy dusted. You know I did not have one drop of champagne. Started reading Jealousy by AR-G. After reading Artaud for a few days, it's like a shotgun to the chest. I like these photos. I feel like my whole body is an amputation. Quitting smoking. Happy New Year and congrats on the nice guy award. Much love
d-
happy new year. my brain hurts today. worked ten hours yesterday, went out with some coworkers after. took some MDMA. drank and spent way too much money.
some nice slaves yesterday. some way cool stuff today too. can't wait to get home from work and look through (yeah i'm heading into work on an E hangover, i'm just THAT MUCH of a badass).
yeah everyone i told that i met biafra was like, 'wow, he's a cool guy? i always thought he would be a total dick.' but yeah, he was a way cool dude. he kissed my roommate on the cheek, and we were leaving and i said 'just to be clear, you're never washing yr face again, yeah?'
to which she replied, 'dude i might just stop taking showers altogether.'
i think i've decided the direction i'm going to go with the book. this first collection is going to be composed more of short pieces. a slightly gentler introduction into this mind of mine. i'll wait til the second book to get into the bizarre sexual material i've been kicking around (can't say too much yet, but i'm making a series of landscapes out of porn; it's pretty awesome).
ok gotta finish getting ready for work. talk soon.
-me.
Aimez-vous Fournier?
Aimez-vous Bruno Latour?
jax & statictick, thanks!!! Happy new year
Happy Days, Dennis.
@ Jax, I tuned in at the anointed time only to get Fred MacAulay... ah, but scrolling down the comments, now I see why. I'll check it tomorrow.
@ DC, Hogmanay is just the Scottish NYE, one of those fancy words they like to make up for whatever reason. Up here it was nice and low-key, friends and a few drinks, Divine - Native Love playing the bells in.
I booked the end of May off work for the Pompidou-MK-Pyre extravaganza. It's on!
I don't know if you're interested in LES MISERABLES, but I know Sypha, for one, plans to see it. I caught it today. I went it with pretty low expectations, and it was better than I thought it would be. Most of it is shot in close-up, which seems to be a sticking point for many people. However, unlike director Tom Hooper's previous film, THE KING'S SPEECH, which threw in tilted angles seemingly at random, there's a clear visual aesthetic at work here. Anne Hathaway's performance sums up the Lars von Trier victimized heroine archetype; her version of "I Dreamed A Dream" blows away the entirety of DANCER IN THE DARK. The film's biggest problems are its dynamics and pacing. Every scene is staged as though it's a peak moment. At 160 minutes, that gets rather tiresome by the halfway mark. Still, I think it's worth seeing.
Hey Steevee, glad you got to see Les Miz. I didn't have probs with the pacing, in fact, I was blown away by it, and I never expected to be. It was exciting to see the first screening in NY (well actually the 2nd, but the first day at Alice Tully Hall).
Dennis, congrats on being best nice guy - you certainly are and make it NOT a stigma...I'll stop trying to change my nice-guy image myself, thanks to you. I guess nice-guys can work (and get published too). We've both got big birthdays coming up and I'm getting ready...are you? Would love to invite you to my pizza and red wine party, but I don't think you'll be here. Let me know if you are (Feb 1) by any chance. Yay for nice guys!
I got to the theater 90 minutes early to buy tickets and then went home, because I was afraid the film would sell out. This turned out to be a good idea because while it didn't sell out, the theater was packed. The audience was really into it, although there was one odd moment where it seemed to laugh at the notion of Hugh Jackman being heterosexual. (Maybe I misunderstood something.) At the end, there were cheers, and when I was in the bathroom afterwards, I heard nothing but praise for the film.
happy new orbit coop and to all you lovely weaklings
what a brilliant day fliest.. thankyou soo much
@jax that sounds exciting.. looking forward to it
@postit happy b'day fella
@davidE i can't believe you don't love the lurhman version of Moulin Rouge.. but then again i do.. so that makes sense
i've been catching up on films and besides this years obvious 21 Jump Street.. Holy Motors.. Doggiewoggiez! Poochiewoochiez!.. This Is Not a Film.. Once Upon A Time in Anatolia.. The Turin Horse i finally got round to seeing Cecil B Demented.. blimey it was gorgeous and made me cry.. john waters deserves a noble teabag prize at the very least
anyway just popping in
love you muchly
riggers
Hey Dennis,
I'd never heard of Carlsen, but I absolutely love what I'm seeing. Thanks so much for the introduction.
Yeah, Carsen did that 'Memoriam' about The Iliad that was what initially got me interested in that piece in the first place. She has this other piece that Guy Davenport did the introduction that I was debating impulse-grabbing yesterday when I asked you.
Been reading Nabokov's memoir. Too early to call it brilliant or whatever but it's pretty great so far. Really wish you'd hurry up on your thing so I'd have something more to read by you.
Might be finishing 'Heavy Rain' tonight. It's uneven, like I said, but my god, when it works, it really, really works.
Final family tally: one long-ish prayer, alleviated by my parents' crazy dachshund.
Til tomorrow
J
also, have you seen my new tumblr. partially inspired by the slaves, I should say: http://centraltxpersonals.tumblr.com/
I've never liked Luhrman -- even back when he was making simpler stuff. The clips I've seen of his new version of Gatsby looks dreadful.
Carolyn Fliest, I love this. This fella's work is just sick and disgusting enough to keep my rapt attention. I can't look away.
postit, Happy Birthday, lad!
Dennis, It's funny, I just watched "Swiss Family Robinson" the other night (mainly because of Tommy Kirk, hehehe) but it's another of those older movies where a lot of the scenes were done on a set and had so many problems re: accuracy in the jungle/animal settings that it was just hilarious. But man, how I wouldn't have liked to rim Tommy Kirk for a few hours back then.
Best Nice Guy, eh? So Beach Sloth has obviously never met you. Hehe, I'm kidding. But you know what? It's things like that that make your work even more dire and transgressive. Good going.
Congratulations on the award! Thank you so much for the suggestions. They're much appreciated.
M. x
postitbreakup: Happy birthday! Hope it's good.
Dennis! Let me know how The Hobbit at 48 is. Maybe you'll sway me to get into it, even if it's awful (maybe especially if it's awful). And thanks for the italics!
Yours,
K
Rigby, Misanthrope, Ken thank you!
dennis/carolyn, this is one of my favorite set of photos i've seen on this blog & there's been tons of awesome photos on here. the whole organic deformity thing is just so lynchian/silent hill/great
Happy New Year!
Bookstore recs in NYC: I'll put in a plug for my local, WORD bookstore in Greenpoint.
The Asger Carlsen gallery is truly amazing.
Didn't go to the party, stayed home and fell asleep in the bathtub listening to Andy Stott's Luxury Problems and almost missed the fireworks, but woke up just in time to see (and film) them in a nice sleepy daze.
Thanks to Carolyn Fliest for introduction to an amazing artist.
postitbreakup, happy birthday!
Dennis, thanks for the shout-out. Today I started a few of my New Years resolutions, such as keeping a diary, typing out a page each from the three Trinity books, and also typing at least one page in my new experimental novel (otherwise known as "The Project"). After getting little done in the way of creative writing in 2012, this year I want to get a lot more writing done.
thanks, james!
Coop, hey man. The Best Nice Guy award, hey? Congratulations!: so entirely deserved, of course. Yet, I have to wonder: does it feel a little disorientating at times to be such a gentleman deviant? :)
Yeah, I'm getting along over here: not much to really give you a heads up about. How are you doing? The photography today is all cool mutant naturalism: fantastic stuff. I need to dig deeper into Carlsen now. Thanks to you and Carolyn for the introduction.
Best to you, dude.
Post a Comment